For our slice of key lime pie we decided to visit the Key Lime Pie Company. This store sells more than just key lime pie. They have chocolate dipped key lime pie slices, ice cream, Tortuga Rum Cake, key lime cookies, key lime juice (of course!), and much more.
Since I was there for pie, I stuck to my guns until I was presented with key lime pie options. They have original key lime pie, pineapple coconut key lime pie, raspberry key lime pie, and mango key lime pie. I opted to try the original (which is what I was there for) and the pineapple coconut. The original was pretty good, I have had better; I think it just needed a tad bit more tartness. Now the pineapple coconut was out of this world! It was a heavenly mixture of coconut cream pie and key lime pie. We decided to get two slices and be on our way.
So when in Key West, visit the Key Lime Pie Company for a slice of heaven.
Oh and just so you know, I did divert a little. I also picked up a key lime body scrub.